À˯Á: ±b¤á ±K½X
¤å¶×ºô­º­¶ | À˯Á | ¥[¤J³Ì·R | ¥»³øPDFª© | | ²Åé 
2012¦~11¤ë9¤é ¬P´Á¤­
 ±zªº¦ì¸m¡G ¤å¶×­º­¶ >> ¤å¦¿¾Ç®ü >> ¥¿¤å
¡i¥´¦L¡j ¡i§ë½Z¡j ¡i±ÀÂË¡j ¡iÃö³¬¡j

²Ó¨ý­õ¾ÇA-Z¡GI for Informal Fallacies


http://paper.wenweipo.com   [2012-11-09]     §Ú­nµû½×

¡@­õ¾Çªº³Ì­«­n¤u¨ã¬OÅÞ¿è¡]logic¡^¡A³o¥]¬A¥¿¤Ï¨â¤è­±¡G1.¥¿­±¡A¬O­nÄY®æ¿í¦uÅÞ¿èªk«h¡F2.¤Ï­±¡A«h­nÁקK¥Ç¤WÂÕ»~¡]fallacy¡A½Æ¼Æfallacies¡^¡CÅÞ¿èÂÕ»~¦³¨â¤jÃþ¡A²Ä¤@Ãþ¥sformal fallacies¡]§Î¦¡ÂÕ»~¡^¡A«ü±À½×§Î¦¡¥»¨­¬O¿ù»~ªº¡CÁ|­Ó¨Ò¤l¡G1.­Y¥L¤¤¤F¤»¦X±m¡A«K·|½Ð¤j®a¦Y¶º¡F2.¥L½Ð¤j®a¦Y¶º¡F3.©Ò¥H¡A¥L¤¤¤F¤»¦X±m¡C³o¬O­Óformal fallacy¡A¦W¥saffirming the consequent¡]ªÖ©w«á¥ó¡B¥HªGÃÒ¦]¡^¡C¦]¬°²Ä¤@¥y¥u¬O»¡If A then B¡]­Y¥Ò«K¤A¡^¡A²Ä¤G¥y¥u»¡B¡]¤A¡^¡A¦ý«o¤£¯à±À½×¥X²Ä¤T¥yA¡]¥Ò¡^¢w­ì¦]¦b©ó¡A¥L¥i¥H¥Ñ©ó¨ä¥L½t¬G¦Ó½Ð¤j®a¦Y¶º¡A¨Ò¦p¤É¾¥[Á~¡C

¡@§Î¦¡ÂÕ»~¤£Ãøµo²{¡A¦]¬°¥u¦³­Y¤zºØ§Î¦¡¡A²ßºD¤F«K«Ü¤Ö¥X¿ù¡C­Ë¬O²Ä¤GÃþÅÞ¿èÂÕ»~½ÆÂø±o¦h¡A¦]¦Ó¤]§ó­nªá®É¶¡ºë¤O¥H¦Ü¸gÅç¥hµo²{©MÁקK¡C¥¦¥sinformal fallacies¡]«D§Î¦¡ÂÕ»~¡^¡A©Ò¦³±À½×§Î¦¡¥H¥~ªºÅÞ¿è¿ù»~³£ÄÝ©ó¦¹Ãþ¡C

¤H¨­§ðÀ» ºzµø½×¾Ú

¡@«D§Î¦¡ÂÕ»~¦³¤Ó¦hºØ¡A¦Ó¥B¦b¤ÀÃþ¤W¤]²³»¡¯É¯Æ¡AÃø¦³©w½×¡C§Ú­Ì¤µ¤Ñ¤£¦p¾Ç²ß¨ä¤¤´XºØ±`¨£ªº¡C­º¥ý¬Oad hominem¡]¶D½Ñ¤H¨­¡^¡A¤]±`¥s¡u¤H¨­§ðÀ»¡v¡A¨º¬OÂǵۧðÀ»¤@­Ó¤Hªº¤H®æ¡B°Ê¾÷©M¦a¦ìµ¥¡A±q¦Ó±À½×¥L´£¥XªºÆ[ÂI¬O¿ù»~ªº¡C¨Ò¦p¡G¡u¥§ªöªº³Ì«á¤é¤lµo¤FºÆ¡A©Ò¥H¥Lªº­õ¾Ç¤£¥i«H¡C¡vµM¦Ó¤@­Ó¤Hªº­õ¾Ç©ÎÆ[ÂI¬O§_¥i«H¡AÀ³¨ú¨M©ó½×¾Ú¥»¨­¡A¦Ó«D¨ä¥L¤£¬Û¤zªº¨Æ¡A¨Ò¦p¥L¬O§_ºÆ¤F¡C¡u¤H¨­§ðÀ»¡vÄÝ©ó¤@­Ó¤jÃþ§O¡A¥srelevance fallacies¡A¤¤¤å±`¥s¡u¤£¬Û¤zÂÕ»~¡v¡A·í¤¤ªºrelevance«üÃöÁp¡B¬Û¤z¡C

¶D½ÑÅv«Â ¿ù¤Þ¤Hª«

¡@»Pad hominem­è¦n¬Û¤Ïªº¬Oappeal to authority¡]¶D½ÑÅv«Â¡^¡A¦]¬°¥L°ò©ó±À±R¬Y¤HªºÀuÂI¡A±q¦Ó±À½×¥L´£¥XªºÆ[ÂI¬O¥¿½Tªº¡C¯d·N¡u¶D½ÑÅv«Â¡v¥»¨­¸g±`¬O¦³®Äªº¡A¨Ò¦pÀNª÷½Í½×¦t©z½×¡A§Ú­Ì·íµM¥i¥H°²³]¬°¦X²zªº¡C¦ý¡u¶D½ÑÅv«Â¡vÂÕ»~«h«ü¶D½Ñ¿ù»~Åv«Â¡A¨Ò¦p¡G¡u·R¦]´µ©Z»{¬°«H¯«¬O·MÄøªº¡A¦]¦¹¯«¤£¦s¦b¡C¡vµM¦Ó·R¦]´µ©Z¥u¬O¬ì¾Ç®a¡A¦Ó¯«¬O§_¦s¦b©|¥i±q·¥¦h¨¤«×±´°Q¡A·R¤ó®Ú¥»µLªk¦¨¬°³o¤è­±ªºÅv«Â¡A¦]¦¹¥H¥Lªº·N¨£§@¨ÌÂk«K¬OÂÕ»~¡C

¡@¥t¤@ºØ±`¨£ÂÕ»~¥scircular reasoning¡]´`Àô½×ÃÒ¡^¡A¦]¬°«e´£¥»¨­¤w°²³]¤Fµ²½×¡A¨Ò¦p¡G¡u¤k©Ê·íµM¦³Åv§Q¡C¤£¹L¤k©Ê¤£À³¾á¥ô¯«Â¾¤H­û¡A¦]¬°¯«Â¾¤H­ûÀ³·í¬O¨k©Ê¡C¡vµM¦Ó°ÝÃDªº©Ò¦b¡A¥¿¬O¬°¦ó¥u¦³¨k©Ê¥i¥H¾á¥ô¯«Â¾¤H­û¡A¦ý½×ªÌ«o¹w¥ý°²³]¤F³oÂI¡C

¡@Informal fallacies©|¦³·¥¦hºØÃþ¡A¦³¥Î¤§¾l¤]«Ü¦nª±¡A¤£¤Ö§ó·|¥O§A«éµM¤j®©©O¡C¡@¡½§E ¥\

³{©P¤­¨£³ø

¬ÛÃö·s»D
ªÀµûÂù»y¹D¡GªøªÌ§Q¯q¬°¥ý ºÉ§Ö­«·s¼fij (2012-11-09) (¹Ï)
²Ó¨ý­õ¾ÇA-Z¡GI for Informal Fallacies (2012-11-09)
§j¤ô¦P¾Ç·|¡G±B«e¬£¹ï «Å¥¬³ß°T (2012-11-09) (¹Ï)
¤¤¤åµø³¥¡G°l·¹¡m¸Ö¡n¤T¦Ê ½Í¥j¤µ¤ñ³ë (2012-11-09)
³Å¼üºtÁ¿¿ý¡G¤¤°ê¬O±j°ê¶Ü¡H¡]¥|¡^ (2012-11-09) (¹Ï)
»P¤¤°ê¯ù¦³¬ù (2012-11-09) (¹Ï)
What's Up?¡GÁü­·¡u®á­}¡vŧ¬ü 810¸U¤á°±¹q (2012-11-07) (¹Ï)
ÃM©O¹C¾Ç¹Î¡G¦P«°¥´ým¾Ô ¾ÖÄ»ª§¾W¿E (2012-11-07)
­^»y¥@¬É¡GMeans ¸ê²£ (2012-11-07) (¹Ï)
«ä«ä®v»y¡G¨Ì¿à¼v¤l±Ð¨| «d®z¦Û¾Ç¯à¤O (2012-11-07)
­^»yµ§Äæ¡G°µ¤û¦n¡H°µ°¨¦n¡H (2012-11-07)
¤k§Å¢w­Y¨¥ (2012-11-07) (¹Ï)
ªÀµûÂù»y¹D¡G²^¨O®ãªo³f¨® ´£¨Ñ»¤¦]§U·~¬É (2012-11-02) (¹Ï)
²Ó¨ý­õ¾ÇA-Z¡GH for History of Western Philosophy (2012-11-02)
§j¤ô¦P¾Ç·|¡G¤£ÃÑprom-posal §A´N¦n¦Ñ¤g (2012-11-02)
¤¤¤åµø³¥¡G¸Ü»¡¿ÀÃÉ (2012-11-02) (¹Ï)
¤¤¦è¤è¤å¤Æ¥æ¬y¨t¦C¡G¤¤°ê¬O±j°ê¶Ü¡H¡]¤T¡^Is China a Power? (3) (2012-11-02) (¹Ï)
®Ñ¥»Â²¤¶ (2012-11-02) (¹Ï)
¬ü³N³Ð·N«Ç¡G¥é¶À¤½±æ´I¬K¤s©~¹Ï¡]²M¤ý­ìªÂ¡^ (2012-11-02) (¹Ï)
What's Up?¡Gæ͹Ü7©¡Á`«a­x ©¥¤h­ð²×¨­°±ÁÉ (2012-10-31) (¹Ï)
¡i¥´¦L¡j ¡i§ë½Z¡j ¡i±ÀÂË¡j ¡i¤W¤@±ø¡j ¡i¦^­¶³»¡j ¡i¤U¤@±ø¡j ¡iÃö³¬¡j
¤å¦¿¾Ç®ü

ÂIÀ»±Æ¦æº]

§ó¦h 

·s»D±MÃD

§ó¦h